Tool comparison 9 min read 2,022 words By LaiUse Editorial Team Reviewed 28 October 2026

Private Property Calculator vs HDB Affordability Calculator: Two Housing Markets, Two Rules

Private Property Calculator vs HDB Affordability Calculator: Use the Private Property Affordability Calculator for a condo or landed-property purchase…

The short answer

Use the Private Property Affordability Calculator for a condo or landed-property purchase financed through a commercial bank or CPF. It is built around the private-property market: TDSR, BSD, ABSD, stamp duties, downpayment, loan tenure, rental income, and several bank-loan interest-rate options. Its monthly affordability calculation also has explicit fields for monthly CPF contributions and other income, which can matter when assessing whether the buyer can service a private mortgage.

Use the HDB Affordability Calculator for an HDB flat. It is built around HDB financing, including the HDB concessionary loan, monthly servicing ratio limits, household income, CPF downpayment, and the effect of the borrower’s age and credit-score profile. A private-property result is not a valid substitute for an HDB result because the maximum loan-to-value ratio, servicing-ratio framework, interest-rate choices, and cost of purchasing are different.

Both calculators process information in the browser and can copy the result to the clipboard. Neither opens a file, downloads a file, or updates automatically while fields are being edited.

What each tool actually does

  1. Private Property Affordability Calculator calculates affordability for private residences such as condos and landed property. Its modes are Bank, CPF, and Custom, giving it three ways to represent financing assumptions.

    The inputs include Property Price (S$), Borrower Age, Loan Type, Loan Tenure (years) — max, and either a bank or custom rate. The interest-rate controls include Bank Loan (SORA Floating), Bank / Package ~%, Your Loan Rate (% p.a.), and Custom Rate. Buyer finances are represented through CPF OA Balance (S$), Extra Cash Fund (S$), and Monthly CPF (S$).

    Its treatment of household cash flow is broader than the HDB tool’s. It asks for Monthly Salary (S$), Monthly Rental Income (S$) — if letting, and Other Monthly Debt (S$). It also includes Other Monthly Income (S$) and an Occupancy Status control, with an Owner-occupied (lower tax rates) option. That makes it the relevant calculator when ownership status affects the cost of the purchase or when rental income offsets mortgage servicing.

    For private-property financing, the key affordability ceiling is generally the bank’s Total Debt Servicing Ratio, or TDSR. Residential private-property borrowing is commonly assessed against a 55% TDSR ceiling, subject to the lender’s underwriting and the borrower’s circumstances. The downpayment is normally at least 20% of the purchase price for a standard owner-occupied private home, which means the mortgage normally reaches no more than 80% of the property value. Exact lending approval remains the lender’s decision.

    The monthly figure should not be treated as a simple “mortgage divided by months.” It brings together the mortgage payment and existing debt obligations against the income available for servicing them. Depending on the financing structure, CPF and other recurring income may affect the assessment. Private property also attracts purchase costs such as BSD and potentially ABSD, so the amount deposited and the amount ultimately borrowed can differ from the property’s advertised price.

    The calculator includes sample data and stores its inputs locally in the browser. It provides a copy action for the result, but it cannot open or download a file, and it does not calculate continuously as the user types.

  2. HDB Affordability Calculator calculates how much an HDB flat may be affordable based on income, servicing-ratio limits, and CPF downpayment. Its modes are Bank, Custom, and HDB.

    The core inputs are Property Price (S$), Your Monthly Income (S$), Combined Household Income (S$), Other Monthly Debt (S$), Borrower Age, and CPF OA Balance (S$). This combination of personal and household income reflects the way HDB affordability is assessed for a household purchase rather than as an isolated private investment.

    Loan choices include HDB Concessionary Loan, Bank Loan (SORA Floating), Your Loan Rate (% p.a.), Custom Rate, 3M SORA Rate (%) editable, and Stress Test Rate (% p.a.). The stress-test field is particularly relevant because HDB affordability is evaluated with a regulatory rate rather than solely at a promotional or negotiated rate. Loan Tenure (years) and Loan Type determine how the mortgage is structured.

    HDB purchases use the Monthly Servicing Ratio, or MSR, rather than the private-property TDSR framework. The standard initial ceiling is generally 30% of household income for households aged 55 and below, with lower ceilings applying at later stages and to older borrowers as the loan is reduced. The exact treatment should be confirmed for the borrower’s circumstances.

    The HDB loan-to-value framework is also different from private financing. HDB downpayment can be as low as 5% of the flat price for eligible buyers using CPF, with alternative downpayment structures available depending on buyer status and funding method. A 5% CPF downpayment can support a mortgage of up to 90% of the price; the 10% and 20% structures correspond to different maximum mortgage ratios. This is a major reason a private-property figure cannot simply be carried over into an HDB purchase.

    The calculator is designed around the combined household income, existing monthly debt, CPF OA balance, mortgage rate, and stress-tested monthly instalment. It processes locally in the browser and can copy the result. It does not offer sample data, persist its inputs locally, open or download files, or update the result automatically while the form is being completed.

When to use each one

Side by side

  1. Input: The private calculator accepts monthly salary, other monthly income, monthly CPF, rental income, CPF OA balance, extra cash, property price, occupancy status, and other debt. The HDB calculator focuses on combined household income, the borrower’s monthly income, CPF OA balance, property price, other debt, age, credit-score profile, and loan assumptions. A user who needs rental income to offset the mortgage belongs in the private-property tool; a user buying with household income is better served by the HDB tool.

  2. Output: Both return an affordability assessment that can be copied to the clipboard. Neither produces a downloadable document. The private result is framed around private financing, taxes, and broader income sources. The HDB result is framed around HDB loan structures and household servicing limits.

  3. Modes: The private calculator offers Bank, CPF, and Custom modes. The HDB calculator offers Bank, Custom, and HDB modes, with a specific HDB concessionary-loan option. The private calculator includes package, SORA-floating, and custom-rate inputs; the HDB calculator includes SORA-floating, custom, editable 3M SORA, stress-test, and concessionary-loan inputs.

  4. Loan and downpayment framework: Private financing normally uses at least a 20% downpayment for a standard owner-occupied private home and applies the TDSR test. HDB financing can use a 5%, 10%, or 20% downpayment structure under the applicable rules and applies MSR limits. These are separate systems, even where both ultimately produce a monthly instalment and a maximum price.

  5. Purchase costs: The private calculator explicitly accounts for BSD, ABSD, and stamp duties, making it the appropriate tool when those private-market costs need to affect the funding calculation. The HDB calculator is not presented as a private-property purchase-cost calculator.

  6. Limitations: The private calculator cannot handle an HDB-specific concessionary loan or stress-test assessment, and the HDB calculator does not expose rental-income, occupancy, BSD, or ABSD inputs. Neither tool submits an application, obtains a loan offer, verifies documents, or guarantees bank or HDB approval.

A worked example

A couple is comparing an HDB flat priced at Property Price (S$) 600,000 with a private condo priced at Property Price (S$) 1,200,000. They should not start by asking which calculator produces the larger number. They should first choose the calculator matching each purchase type and test the financing rules that actually apply.

For the HDB option, they would open the HDB Affordability Calculator and enter Combined Household Income (S$), Your Monthly Income (S$), the existing Other Monthly Debt (S$), and the available CPF OA Balance (S$). In the HDB mode, they can select HDB Concessionary Loan, enter a Loan Tenure (years), and review the result using Stress Test Rate (% p.a.). They can then change to the Bank or Custom mode, enter a floating or custom rate, and compare how the monthly figure responds. The borrower’s Borrower Age and Credit Score Profile can also be supplied.

For the condo, they would use the Private Property Affordability Calculator. They would enter the Property Price (S$), Monthly Salary (S$), Monthly CPF (S$), Other Monthly Debt (S$), and available CPF OA Balance (S$). If the unit will be let, they can add Monthly Rental Income (S$) — if letting. They can choose Bank, CPF, or Custom mode, select Bank Loan (SORA Floating) or another rate, set the maximum Loan Tenure (years) — max, and review the result. The private calculator also allows them to identify the Occupancy Status and apply Owner-occupied (lower tax rates) where relevant. Once each result is copied, the couple can compare like with like: price, downpayment, mortgage, recurring servicing burden, and the purchase costs specific to that market.

Where these tools do not help

Frequently asked questions

Can the Private Property Affordability Calculator assess an HDB flat?
No. It is designed for condos and landed property and does not provide the HDB concessionary-loan or stress-test framework. Use the HDB calculator for an HDB purchase.

Can the HDB calculator assess a condo?
It can calculate a general HDB-style affordability scenario, but it is the wrong tool for a private-property transaction because it does not include private purchase taxes or the private calculator’s rental-income, CPF-contribution, and occupancy inputs.

Does the HDB calculator use only the buyer’s salary?
No. It includes both Your Monthly Income (S$) and Combined Household Income (S$), allowing household income to be considered alongside the individual borrower’s income.

Does the private calculator include rental income?
Yes. Monthly Rental Income (S$) — if letting is an explicit input, so a private purchase with a tenant can be evaluated with that income included.

Which calculator includes private-property purchase taxes?
The Private Property Affordability Calculator. Its stated scope includes BSD, ABSD, and stamp duties, which are relevant to private purchases but are not part of the HDB tool’s stated scope.

Are these results updated live while I type?
No. Both calculators require the calculation to be run rather than continuously updating as fields change.

Can I save or download the results?
Both calculators can copy a result to the clipboard, but neither can download a file. The private calculator also provides sample data; the HDB calculator does not.

The tools in this guide: private property calculator · hdb affordability calculator — each runs in your browser, so your data stays on your device.

Browse every guide · Read the blog · About LaiUse